| | | Market Moves | The Trump administration’s finalized rate boost for Medicare Advantage plans came out after the markets closed Monday. Although stock prices of major insurers jumped in after-hours trading, Tuesday’s increases provided a clearer picture of investor reaction. Here is a breakdown of the one-day increases per share, ranked in order of Medicare Advantage market share: - UnitedHealth Group: $308 (9 percent increase)
- Humana: $197 (8 percent increase)
- CVS Health: $78 (nearly 7 percent increase)
- Elevance: $312 (3 percent increase)
- Centene: $36 (nearly 3 percent increase)
“This update is significantly better for [the insurance] industry for plan year 2027 setting up potentially two years of earnings growth,” Raymond James analyst Chris Meekins wrote in a client alert Monday. As I covered in Monday’s Health Brief, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services finalized a 2.48 percent payment bump for Medicare Advantage plans — equivalent to $13 billion more for plans next year. When the Trump administration proposed a 0.09 percent payment boost in January, the stock prices for insurers tumbled. For the largest companies, Tuesday’s gains haven’t yet made up for those overall losses. Insurers had warned that the proposed pay bump ultimately amounted to a cut that could lead plans to exit markets, reduce benefits or raise costs for consumers. Meekins in January said it would be “political suicide” for the administration to finalize a payment rate that spurs Medicare Advantage cuts in a midterm election year. What to watch: It’s unclear whether plans will further contract their benefit offerings or retreat from certain markets despite the pay raise. Health care costs continue to rise faster than overall inflation, insurers have warned. “While the final rate notice is an improvement, pressure on the Medicare Advantage program remains. Health care costs continue to rise, driven by higher utilization, workforce shortages, and inflation across the health care system,” the Better Medicare Alliance said in an alert on Tuesday. “Even with this stronger final rate, the program will continue to face real financial pressure that can make it harder to preserve affordability and maintain benefits for beneficiaries.” → The picture will become clearer in the coming weeks as health insurers kick off their first-quarter earnings calls: UnitedHealth Group is scheduled to brief investors on April 21, Humana is having its Q1 call on April 29, and CVS Health has its first earnings call of 2026 scheduled for May 6. During a first-quarter earnings call in February, Steve Nelson, the president of CVS Health-owned Aetna, told investors that the company has made changes to absorb the hit from the lower-than-anticipated proposed rate. Nelson said at the time that the company is “well positioned” despite the proposal. → In addition to raising the amount Medicare Advantage plans can expect to receive, CMS decided to delay some of the changes it had proposed to the way reimbursement rates are calculated. This also helped bump up the amount insurers can expect to receive next year. Administration officials would not clarify when they would reconsider that reform. |