Despite lacking a consistent lineup, sound, or image, the girl group is bigger than ever.
 

AUGUST 21, 2026

 

ALBUM REVIEW

Katseye Is a Baffling Success Despite lacking a consistent lineup, sound, or image, the girl group is bigger than ever.

By Craig Jenkins

Photo: HYBE LABELS via YouTube

Katseye is taking off like a rocket ship that’s losing bits of mass as it gains altitude. Their new EP, Wild, is reportedly about to debut at No. 1 as the biggest release from a girl group in the streaming era. But it has been an intermittently baffling, sometimes worrying year for the international sextet, who formed in 2023 on the competitive reality series The Debut: Dream Academy. In February, the group’s label, K-pop machine Hybe, announced fan favorite Manon Bannerman’s indefinite hiatus citing health reasons — which she seemed to challenge by attending Coachella two months later even as the rest of the group performed there without her. Her departure and a lack of clarity from management fed speculation in the press and in their fandom full of children and teens that there’s potentially a deeper problem and she may never return. (Manon is not featured on Wild but shows up in archival footage in the new Katseye: Wild Hearts documentary, so no new tea is spilled there.) Then this month, another member, Sophia Laforteza, announced her temporary health hiatus. Down a third of its crew (and periodically appearing as a trio), the quartet-for-now seeks modern girl-group chart history while nagged by uncertainty and controversy that extends to their music.

READ MORE
 

Subscribe now to get unlimited access to everything New York, including subscriber-only newsletters, exclusive perks, the New York app, and more.

Subscribe Now
 

News Feed

Celebrity gossip, industry updates, and beyond.

➼ Julia Stiles saved the last dance for ABC.

➼ Meghan Markle may sparkle on TV again. 

➼ Not a drill: It's The Pitt season three teaser.

➼ Movies Fantasy League, explained in 30 seconds.

 
Movies Fantasy League

MFL Is Back

Build a team of movies to win grand prizes. 

DRAFT NOW
 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about OpenWeb
 

The Critics, In Short

Alison Willmore on Dreams In Nightmares

Shatara Michelle Ford’s follow-up to their terrific 2019 debut, Test Pattern, is a country-spanning road-trip movie that’s both more expansive and messier, delving into the relationships a trio of queer Black femmes have with one another and with a country with punishingly rigid (and perpetually racist) guide rails around how people are expected to exist. Z (Denée Benton), Tasha (Sasha Compère), and Lauren (Dezi Bing) set off for the Midwest to check on a friend who vanished off the grid two months ago, and in doing so, grapple with whether the lives they want to live are possible under the American ethos.

Enjoy our reviews? Sign up for The Critics weekly newsletter.

 

Today in Culture

 

Billy Idol’s Idol

“Rebel Yell,” Live Aid, Michael Jackson: Steve Stevens has stories.

Billy Idol’s Idol

 

Jason Statham Rips a Guy’s Face Open With a Padlock in Mutiny

Honestly, pretty innovative.

Jason Statham Rips a Guy’s Face Open With a Padlock in <em>Mutiny</em>

 

Did You Know There’s a New Claire Denis Film Out?

Starring Matt Dillon and Isaach de Bankolé, The Fence doesn’t deserve to disappear.

Did You Know There’s a New Claire Denis Film Out?