The Book Review: Novelists as critics
Plus: new books to read this week.
Books
September 15, 2026
An illustration has portions of 21 book covers arranged in rows on a yellow gradient background.

Dear readers,

We give a lot of thought to matching reviewers with the books they write about, and often the brainstorming leads us to ingenious places. I was thrilled when Dana Spiotta, who is among my favorite living American novelists, reviewed Zayd Ayers Dohrn’s memoir for the Book Review a few months ago. A novelist who’s imagined the lives of American radicals reviewing a book by the son of actual radicals? Fabulous! (Are you at all interested in hearing more about our assigning process? Send your questions to me at books@nytimes.com; I might answer a handful down the road.)

This week, the author Joseph O’Neill reviewed Jacob Weisberg’s “Profiles in Cowardice,” a womp-womp Trump-era bookend to John F. Kennedy’s collection of heroic biographies with a similar title. O’Neill, who is perhaps best known for his book “Netherland,” is an ambidextrous novelist-critic equally skilled in both modes. Given his literary interests, it is perhaps unsurprising that O’Neill is also drawn to write essays about politics. His novels deal in transience and wanderers, usually anchored by educated, sensitive men trying to make sense of an absurd world around them.

When we profiled O’Neill two years ago, on the occasion of his novel “Godwin,” the subject of his political writing of course came up, and he said that he sees it as “quite separate from my efforts at writing fiction.” His novels, he went on, “are inevitably political, too, but I hope not in a didactic way. One of the basic objectives of writing — or of painting, or making music — is to make an interpretable thing of language that will transcend one’s normal dreary take on the world.”

That’s a worthy goal of criticism, too, I’d say. Take a look at O’Neill’s review for us and see what he means. It’s a real pleasure to watch writers tackling the issues of the day in different modes, whether or not you agree with their take on the world.

See you on Friday.

LOOKING FOR YOUR NEXT BOOK TO READ?

Article Image

7 New Books We Love This Week

Reading recommendations from critics and editors at The New York Times.

An illustration has portions of 21 book covers arranged in rows on a yellow gradient background.

21 Books Coming in September

Novels by Marlon James, Emma Cline, Hernan Diaz and John Green; nonfiction by Emily Wilson and Robert Kolker; and more.

RECENT BOOK REVIEWS

A collage-style illustration that includes robot heads coming out of a computer screen, rocket ships, disembodied hands, barbed wire and a Christian cross.

Nonfiction

Why the Rich and Powerful Have Become So Fatalistic

In “End Times Fascism,” Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor argue that apocalyptic ideology has taken hold over American elites.

By Damon Linker

A black-and-white photograph of a narrow, dagger-shaped structure jutting into the cloudy gray sky of postwar London.

fiction

Kate Atkinson’s Quirky Murder Mystery Is Steeped in Postwar Malaise

“Our Noble Selves” takes place amid the 1951 Festival of Britain, when a traumatized ex-war reporter and P.O.W. goes from government cog to murder suspect.

By Sadie Stein

A black-and-white photograph of a man and a woman leaning against a tree in a palm grove.

Nonfiction

The Sexual Secret That Foiled a Communist Plot

In “Redwood,” Ben Macintyre tells the story of a Russian spy in Iran who betrayed his country in exchange for an unusual request.

By Joseph Finder

A photo of a pregnant woman’s silhouette, viewed from the side through a translucent curtain.

Fiction

She Had 7 Pregnancies in 10 Years, All for a Hefty Paycheck

In Sarah Anderson’s satirical novel, “Fallow,” a debt-laden woman becomes a professional surrogate for a corporate behemoth.

By Hilary Leichter

A black-and-white photograph of two women in furs walking side-by-side and holding signs that protest fascism.

Nonfiction

Everyone Was Fighting Fascism. Why Couldn’t They Get Along?

In “A Shadow Over the World,” William I. Hitchcock shows how the early struggle against totalitarianism was rife with contradictions.

By Kevin Peraino

This illustration shows a glowing woman standing in the middle of a divided landscape. On one side, there’s a ruined building; on the other, there’s a shiny, new door. Overall the image gives the sense that we’re looking at two different versions of the same scene.

Fiction

This Novel Asks: Who Will You Be at the End of the World?

In “Exit Party,” by Emily St. John Mandel, two versions of America’s future crash into each other.

By Lincoln Michel

A photograph of a man in a dark coat and fedora hat.

Nonfiction

Notes From Underground (and the Street, Disco, Porn Set and More)

Two career-spanning essay collections, from Nik Cohn and Jerry Stahl, revel in life’s margins and recapture auras past.

By Dwight Garner

An illustration of a Black man in a blue suit standing at a lectern on stage.

Fiction

Freed From Slavery but Far From Free

Sebastian Barry’s new novel tours a post-Civil War America where cruelty is ever-present but love endures.

By Ian McGuire

We hope you’ve enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times.

Love this email? Forward to a friend.

Want this email? Sign-up here.

Have a suggestion for this email? Then send us a note at books@nytimes.com.

If you received this newsletter from someone else, subscribe here.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Books from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Books, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

xwhatsapp

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

Zeta LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018